Common Mistakes To Avoid In eCommerce CRO

In the fast-paced world of eCommerce, a small shift can have a massive impact. Your competitors are constantly testing, optimising, and refining their strategies to take conversion through the roof. So, why are you still stuck in the slow lane? A failed CRO strategy doesn't just mean a few lost sales; it means you're leaving a fortune on the table. It means every penny spent on marketing and advertising is being wasted on a leaky bucket. If you're serious about long-term growth, you can’t afford to repeat the same mistakes.

At WIRO, we’ve audited and optimised countless Shopify and Shopify Plus stores. But we see the common mistakes, and many of them can be avoided with a small shift in focus that usually drives real, measurable improvements and successful results for CRO teams.

1. Ignoring Data and Relying on Assumptions

The biggest CRO sin? Guessing. Many founders decide to change layouts, colours, or CTAs based on gut feel or worse, because “a competitor is doing it.” But understand - your customers are not theirs.

Every decision must be made based on collected data. Use heatmaps, funnel analysis, session recordings and customer surveys to understand deeper where users drop off. Track the “why” behind abandoned carts. Without data, you’re flying blind. Here’s how to create a data-driven CRO strategy that avoids guesswork

2. Overcomplicating the User Journey

In the UK, shoppers are spoilt for choice. If your checkout requires account creation before showing delivery costs, expect drop-offs. The unnecessary steps or multiple CTAs causes complexity and kills conversions.

Keep navigation simple by stripping out unnecessary steps. Use guest checkout and autofill where possible to simplify the user journey. The smoother the path from landing page to purchase, the more sales you’ll recover.

3. Neglecting Mobile Optimisation

Mobile commerce now dominates UK eCommerce. Yet many retailers still treat mobile as an afterthought cramming desktop designs onto smaller screens.

A mobile-first approach is important to consider. Your site must have tappable buttons, legible typography, and a clean design. A clunky mobile store erodes trust in seconds.

4. Making Changes Without Proper A/B Testing

Changing a button colour because “it looks nicer” is not a CRO strategy it’s gambling.

Prioritise A/B testing on the pages with more traffic to prove which changes increase conversions. From headlines to product images, test systematically. Data-driven experimentation ensures you’re improving, not regressing.

5. Focusing on Traffic Instead of Conversions

UK retailers often obsess over visitor numbers. But traffic alone is vanity. What matters is the percentage who actually buy.

Optimising your existing traffic is almost always more cost-effective than chasing more clicks. CRO ensures your paid ads, SEO, and email campaigns work harder. If you’re unsure what benchmarks to aim for, read our breakdown of what a good eCommerce conversion rate looks like.

6. Overloading Pages With Too Many Elements

We’ve seen countless eCommerce stores cluttered with pop-ups, banners, and competing messages. The result? Decision paralysis.

Attention is finite. Strip back the noise and let your product and CTA command focus. Clarity always beats clutter.

7. Ignoring Micro & Nano Conversions

A “conversion” isn’t always a purchase. Newsletter sign-ups, video plays, product views, search usage, adding to wish list these micro conversions are often ignored as they don’t generate revenue.

But these behaviours are solid indicators of purchase intent. If you ignore them, you miss the signals that drive bigger wins. Tracking small actions helps identify where customers drop off before checkout and which nudges influence purchase decisions. Optimising these micro-steps compounds into major gains.

8. Using Generic CTAs That Don’t Drive Action

“Click Here.” “Shop Now.” These are empty phrases. A strong CTA is clear, benefit-led, and urgent.

Instead of “Add to Cart,” use language that ties to the customer’s need:

• “Secure Your Discount Today”
• “Get Free UK Delivery Now”

9. Failure to Segment Audiences

New visitors need reassurance. Returning customers need speed. High-value buyers may respond to exclusivity, while bargain hunters care about discounts. If you serve the same experience to everyone, you’ll convert fewer of them. Segmentation is important for making data-driven decisions.

Segment your audiences by behaviour, devices, geography, or customer lifetime value and tailor experiences accordingly.

10. Ignoring Site Speed and Technical Performance

A one-second delay in page load time can reduce conversions by up to 7%. Therefore, regularly auditing your site’s performance is essential. Compress images, use a reliable hosting provider, and remove bloated code. A fast, frictionless site builds trust and improves your SEO ranking too. For a step-by-step approach, check out our guide on complete guide to optimising your Shopify store performance.

Conclusion

If you're serious about scaling your eCommerce business, you need to move beyond outdated practices and embrace a data-driven, customer-centric approach. Stop making these amateur mistakes and start optimising for growth.

At WIRO, we help ambitious home and lifestyle brands do just that turning data into decisions that drive measurable revenue.

👉 Ready to stop gambling with your store’s performance? Get in touch with WIRO and let’s optimise your conversions.
‍