August 4, 2025

Shopify Markets vs Global Expansion: What Shopify Plus Brands Get Wrong in 2025

Growth
Shopify
August 4, 2025

Shopify Markets vs Global Expansion: What Shopify Plus Brands Get Wrong in 2025

Growth
Shopify

International expansion isn’t a future ambition for Shopify Plus brands anymore, it’s a commercial necessity.

UK-based merchants are seeing international demand earlier than ever, driven by global paid media, marketplaces, and social discovery. But while Shopify makes cross-border selling look deceptively simple, the reality is far more complex.

At WIRO, we’ve supported Shopify merchants at every stage of global expansion from testing a single EU market using Shopify Markets to building fully localised, multi-region ecommerce operations. And here’s the truth most brands discover too late:

Shopify Markets is a powerful tool but it is not a global expansion strategy.

TL;DR

  • Shopify Markets makes international selling easier, but it is not a complete global expansion strategy
  • It works best for testing demand in new regions and consolidating early international revenue
  • Shopify Plus brands often struggle when they rely on Markets without localisation, CRO, and operational planning
  • True global expansion requires local UX, payments, fulfilment, compliance, and customer support
  • Brands that scale internationally successfully treat Shopify Markets as a foundation, not the finish line
  • WIRO helps Shopify Plus brands move from market testing to scalable global growth without sacrificing performance

The Rise of Global eCommerce: Why It Matters in 2025

eCommerce is no longer local by default.

According to Statista, global retail eCommerce sales are forecast to surpass $8 trillion by 2027. Consumers now expect seamless cross-border experiences from currency and checkout to customer service and delivery.

For UK merchants, this presents a huge opportunity. But it also introduces new layers of complexity. Every new market adds variables: new taxes, new regulations, new expectations.

What is Shopify Markets? An Overview

Shopify Markets is Shopify’s in-platform solution designed to help brands manage international selling from a single storefront.

With Markets, merchants can:

  • Automatically convert currencies
  • Set up localised domains and languages
  • Estimate duties and taxes at checkout
  • Manage product availability by region
  • Customise the customer experience per market

It’s built for simplicity giving growing merchants a scalable way to test and expand into new regions without creating multiple storefronts.

WIRO Testimonial Quote
"Shopify Markets is a brilliant launchpad for international selling. But it’s only as good as the strategy behind it" – Amy Highland, Head of Operations at WIRO

Shopify Markets on Shopify Plus: What It Can and Can’t Do

Shopify Markets is often misunderstood as a complete international solution, especially by fast-scaling Shopify Plus brands.

On Plus, Markets works best as:

  • A market validation tool
  • A way to consolidate early international revenue
  • A foundation for future localisation

Where it struggles:

  • Deep UX localisation
  • Complex tax and compliance structures
  • Region-specific CRO
  • Enterprise fulfilment logic

This is where most Shopify Plus brands stall not because of the platform, but because the strategy stops too early.

Understanding Global Expansion: A Strategic Perspective

Going global isn’t just about enabling new regions. It’s about rebuilding your customer experience for an entirely different audience sometimes multiple audiences.

Global expansion demands:

  • Market-specific messaging and UX
  • Fulfilment infrastructure and return networks
  • Legal and tax compliance
  • Localised payments and customer support
  • Operational resilience

We’ve worked with brands that opened up their store to 10+ markets overnight and saw poor conversions across all of them. Why? Because they hadn't done the groundwork.

Key Differences Between Shopify Markets and Full-Scale Global Expansion

Aspect Shopify Markets Strategic Global Expansion
Setup Within Shopify admin End-to-end planning & execution
Localisation Currency, language, duties Messaging, UX, trust signals, CX
Payments Local currency Country-preferred methods (e.g. Klarna, Sofort, iDEAL)
Fulfilment Self-managed 3PL/local warehousing
Compliance Basic tax/VAT tools Full legal, tax, and data compliance
Ideal For Testing markets Scaling international growth

Shopify Markets gets you going. But expansion at scale requires much more  and that’s where most brands trip up.

When to Use Shopify Markets vs When to Scale Further

Use Shopify Markets when:

  • You want to test demand in one or two international regions
  • You have limited team resources or want to avoid managing multiple stores
  • You’re still early in your global strategy and need speed to market

Invest in full global expansion when:

  • International revenue is growing and becoming a core channel
  • You want to offer competitive delivery, returns, and payment options
  • Your team is ready to operationalise multiple regions with purpose-built processes

Challenges of Going Global (and How These Tools Help)

1. Localisation Gaps

Many brands mistake translation for localisation. But real localisation means adapting tone, visuals, product curation, and even pricing strategies for each market.

Markets gives you tools  but it's your responsibility to make the experience resonate.

2. Operational Complexity

Returns, shipping costs, customs, tax reporting they all add friction. Markets provides basic tooling, but scaling requires strategic fulfilment and logistics partners.

3. Compliance Blind Spots

GDPR. UK to EU VAT. Cookie consent. Payment fraud. Compliance doesn’t scale linearly it spikes. You need proactive planning, not just platform automation.

Real-World Examples: How Brands Are Scaling Internationally

Avery Row – Expanding into Europe with Shopify Markets

We supported Avery Row, a sustainable baby and toddler brand, in refining their EU presence using Shopify Markets. But the wins came not from turning Markets “on” they came from layered strategy: faster EU fulfilment, geo-specific messaging, and performance-led CRO. The result? Record Add-to-Cart rates and YoY growth in the double digits.

Read the full Shopify Markets international expansion case study here.

Premium Interiors Brand – Building for the Middle East

Another WIRO client a high-end interiors brand saw demand spike in the Middle East. But instead of relying solely on platform tooling, we helped them develop a full localisation plan: translated product content, localised delivery options, trust-building UX changes, and tailored payment methods. The result? Their international return rate dropped, while LTV grew.

Tips for Choosing the Right Global eCommerce Strategy

  1. Start small, but think long-term — Use Shopify Markets to test regions, but build with an eye on future localisation.
  2. Use data to decide — Prioritise markets based on traffic, demand, and shipping feasibility not trend-chasing.
  3. Invest in customer experience — From payment trust signals to translated PDPs, every detail matters more internationally.
  4. Build infrastructure early — Delays in returns, duties confusion, or tax issues can kill brand trust fast.
  5. Work with a partner — Global growth isn’t a solo sport. Strategy, tech, and compliance need senior-level attention.'

Shopify Markets vs Full Global Expansion: Quick Summary

Shopify Markets is best for:

  • Testing international demand quickly
  • Early-stage global revenue
  • Lean teams without regional operations

Full global expansion is required when:

  • International revenue exceeds 20–30%
  • Local payment methods affect conversion
  • Returns, duties, or delivery friction increase
  • Brand trust varies by region

Final Thoughts: Building a Borderless Brand

Shopify Markets offers powerful functionality  but it’s a tool, not a strategy.

To win in international eCommerce, you need to do more than convert currency. You need to think like a local, operate like a global brand, and optimise like a CRO specialist.

At WIRO, we combine Shopify Plus expertise with real-world commercial thinking to help brands move from local to global without losing control or performance.

If you’re serious about building a scalable, sustainable international eCommerce business let’s have a conversation.

FAQ

What is Shopify Markets and how does it work? +
Shopify Markets is a built-in tool that lets merchants sell internationally from a single Shopify store. It enables currency conversion, market-specific domains, local languages, and tax/duty calculations. It’s a great starting point for testing new regions, but scaling globally requires deeper localisation and operational planning.
Is Shopify Markets enough for Shopify Plus international growth? +
For most Shopify Plus brands, no. Shopify Markets helps launch new regions quickly, but long-term international growth requires localisation, logistics, compliance, and CRO. Shopify Markets supports strategy, it doesn’t replace it.
What’s the difference between global expansion and using Shopify Markets? +
Shopify Markets is a tool within the Shopify platform. Global expansion is a broader strategy that includes fulfilment, compliance, marketing, UX localisation, customer support, and long-term operational planning. Shopify Markets supports expansion it doesn’t replace it.
Can I use Shopify Markets for multiple countries at once? +
Yes, you can configure and manage multiple regions simultaneously through Shopify Markets. Each market can have its own pricing, content, domains, and checkout settings. However, the more markets you manage, the more complex the operations become—that’s where a strategic partner like WIRO can add value.
How do I know if I’m ready to expand globally? +
Start by evaluating your international traffic, demand patterns, and fulfilment capacity. If you’re already seeing strong interest from specific regions, and your operations can support global logistics and returns, you may be ready to scale. A full audit can help you prioritise the right markets and avoid costly missteps.
Amy Highland
Head Of Operations